Bob Piper
Bob Piper










Designed by Wibbler
Produced by Wibbler
Hosted by BatchTarget



Why I won't be voting in Iain Dale's poll of top bloggers   » Permalink  |  TrackBack (0)

I suspect most of you are already aware of it, but I'll post it anyway.

Iain Dale is compiling his annual list of the top UK political bloggers, and he wants your help. You have until 15th August to vote for your favourites.

I have mixed feelings about this. Although some on the left say it is just another Iain Dale ego trip, I don't actually agree. I think it has provided a valuable service to political blogging and helped to raise people's awareness of the range of blogs 'on the market'. This blog has featured quite highly in the left/Labour blogging category in the last couple of years, and I know from looking at the referring sites that quite a lot of traffic comes via Iain's list.

So... that's the good points out of the way. However, I won't be participating in the exercise this year, and I would quite understand it if other left blogs did the same. Over the last year there have been a few occasions when Iain Dale has been rude and derogatory about the standard of 'left' blogs. Whilst I recognise the top right wing bloggers currently have more traffic, that doesn't mean they are better quality. The Sun sells 6 times more daily newspapers than The Financial Times, but that doesn't make it quality. I think it is well out of order to describe left wing blogs as comics, and then ask people to help you to compile a list of the best of them.

So, sorry, Skipper, Unity, Paul Linford, Cassilis, Uncle Tom Watson and all... you won't be getting my vote this year... although I hope you all do well in the poll.

Update: I didn't realise it when I posted this, but Liberal Conspiracy is adopting pretty much the same line.

Posted by bobpiper on July 21, 2008, 6:50 PM  |  view comments (16) or add another



Trackbacks
TrackBack Link: http://www.bobpiper.co.uk/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2278


Comments (or post a new one)

Maggie Thatcher Fan said:
July 21, 2008 7:19 PM | permalink

Rude about Left wing blogs..... The only one worth reading is..oops forgotten which one it was!.
What you forget Bob is the blogs are a reflection of the times,so go on, dont be a spoilsport............. it couldnt be perhaps that you know that a Labour blog has no chance of winning period.




Bob Piper said:
July 21, 2008 8:14 PM | permalink

It's brilliant when someone comes to read your blog and then says there is only one worth reading!

However, your memory must be as 'distracted' as the old bat of Finchley herself if you can't retain the name for even a few seconds.

Also, you clearly haven't got a clue what you are talking about. I strongly suspect a 'left' blogger will finish top (or win, if that's what you want to call it) of the top 100 left bloggers list.

Muppet!




newmania said:
July 21, 2008 8:23 PM | permalink

Is this like the Pistols refusing to play Top of The Pops ?




Maggie Thatcher Fan said:
July 21, 2008 9:31 PM | permalink

You really are rather unpleasant are'nt you...
You may have a point in the fact that votes are being split into categories for blog awards, but theres no need to be so damned rude. Thats not how understood it. I was sent a e mail asking to vote for my top 10 (Dont worry, You weren't in it, hadnt heard of your insignificant blog before.)

As regards to manners, First you call me a muppet, then you refer to Mrs Thatcher in an extremely disparaging manner. Rather nasty in fact. You can take your blog and stick it. I dont need abuse from someone like you
Enjoy a decade or two in opposition, itll humble you a bit no doubt..




Bob Piper said:
July 21, 2008 9:45 PM | permalink

Actually, I think you will find I made disparaging remarks about the old witch before I called you a muppet.

Just for accuracy.




Silent Hunter said:
July 21, 2008 11:02 PM | permalink

Maggie Thatcher Fan:

"You really are rather unpleasant are'nt you..."

Yes...........He is! :O)

But it's bloody useful being able to post his rants across the blogosphere as an example of how Labour react to dissent. LOL




Bob Piper said:
July 21, 2008 11:23 PM | permalink

Nice to see you back, David... or do I have to call you Silent.




Silent Hunter said:
July 21, 2008 11:39 PM | permalink

Either suits me B O B!

Is that the hand of friendship being proferred perchance? ;O)

Ah!..........if only you were sincere about that.

I take it that you've calmed down since our last little spat?




Mr. Jolly said:
July 22, 2008 12:55 AM | permalink

Aww. C'mon Bob. Yes Mrs. Dale can some times be disparaging about left-wing blogs. Not to put too fine a point upon it, I suspect your own praise of right-wing blogs has been rather thin on the ground as well. That's no reason not to take part surely? At the moment right wing blogs seem to be more in favour with the general public (I wonder why that should be?), however, in a few years time who knows if that will still be the case? To declare "I'm not playing because the other side are more popular" just sounds like bad sportsmanship.
Or on the other hand, perhaps you lefties are just 'Frit'?




Bob Piper said:
July 22, 2008 8:26 AM | permalink

I may have been critical of right-wing blogs Mr Jolly (now, that's a proper blog tag - not like the pretentious tit calling himself 'Silent Hunter') but if I had I would hardly expect them to help me compile a list.

It isn't about right-wing blogs being more popular. I accept that. It's so much easier to be critical in opposition - particularly when the Government is as inept as the current one. I've no idea what we could be 'frit' of though, that just sounded like a playground jibe when the withered old bag said it, and it doesn't sound any more grown up now.




Ernesto said:
July 22, 2008 8:56 AM | permalink

Maggie Thatcher's Fanny and Silent Hunter -

Unpleasant? You ain't seen nothin' yet!!!




Letters From A Tory said:
July 22, 2008 10:17 AM | permalink

I don't see why Iain Dale compiling this list makes any difference. If the left-wing blogs want to throw in the towel then fair enough, but surely it's best for everyone if we get the most accurate reflection possible the strength of respective blogospheres?




Cassilis said:
July 22, 2008 10:32 AM | permalink

I understand where you & LC are coming from Bob but I'm not sure it's the wisest approach (and not because you kindly suggested a vote for me or because of my loose association with Mr D).

The main argument here is that Iain's list / book is the only game in town, however flawed. Yes we could all probably write the eventual top 10 now (1. Guido 2. Iain etc.) but that's the logic of those you might have met on the doorstep 20 years ago asking the point in voting Labour, the result was a foregone conclusion so why bother?

If blogs like yours and LC (I've urged Sunny along the same lines elsewhere this morning) decided to 'flame' these lists, get passionate about it and urge readers to vote then you could redress the balance a bit in favour of some of the excellent blogs from the left that get too little attention (Tom F, Bill, Hopi, Don P etc.) not to mention some of the more moderate and less swivel-eyed on the right.

Granted the top 10 might not change that much but the overall 100 could shift significantly. Then, when the book & list get the profile it inevitably will more & more people will check out these other blogs and audiences will grow - it's an organic thing but it won't take off without a push from those already in the game....

And yes I agree that Iain hasn't been entirely fair to blogs on the left - don't think that changes the thrust of this though....




Bob Piper said:
July 22, 2008 10:51 AM | permalink

LFaT, it isn't a question of throwing the towel in. Like a lot of people here you are misreading this. My blog featured fairly highly in Iain's list last year and the year before (top 5 of left bloggers I think) so its not sour grapes.

Liam, together with a few other people, last year I spent a fair bit of time assisting Iain with the book. I wrote one of the introductions, and spent ages poring over a convoluted spreadsheet of shortlisted blogs helping to mark them. And I think we came up with a pretty good list of left-ish bloggers.

Only to find Iain on a few occasions since dismissing those blogs as 'rubbish', which frankly, I found bloody offensive because there were some damned good bloggers on that list.

So, I'm not urging a boycott, and I did plug the poll... I'm just explaining why I won't bother this year.




jailhouselawyer said:
July 22, 2008 12:22 PM | permalink

In relation to Liberal Conspiracy, I wonder how many of its readers it takes to change a light bulb?




Paulie said:
August 8, 2008 6:02 PM | permalink

I thought that this was a good take on blog-rankings a while ago:

http://stumblingandmumbling.typepad.com/stumbling_and_mumbling/2007/09/against-web-ran.html

.. not just because it gave mine a mench, either...





Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)